A Leading Independent Northeast Ohio Home, Auto, Health & Life Insurance Company


“I am an experienced agent you can trust because I do not work for any single insurance company, I work for you. I analyze your special needs and circumstances and find you the very best insurance coverage for your needs.”

Denise Biats

Your Protection Is Our Priority!

Welcome to Eveningstar Insurance, an independent insurance agency serving Northeast Ohio, including Summit, Stark, and Portage counties. With over 20 years of experience in the insurance industry, we have accumulated a wealth of knowledge and expertise in assessing insurance needs, understanding coverage options, and navigating the complexities of insurance policies. This expertise allows us to provide you with personalized recommendations and guidance tailored to your unique needs and circumstances, ensuring you have the right coverage in place to protect yourself and your assets.

Our team of experienced insurance professionals will work with you to understand your unique needs and provide tailored insurance solutions that offer you the right coverage at competitive rates. And, our commitment to you is simple, and that is to be a trusted insurance partner for our community and to provide reliable and comprehensive insurance solutions to individuals, families, and businesses.

There are several compelling reasons why working with an experienced independent insurance agent can be advantageous for individuals seeking home, auto, health, life, business, umbrella, recreational vehicles, and professional liability insurance.

Choice & Flexibility Image

Choice & Flexibility

As an independent insurance agent, we are not tied to any specific insurance company, but rather have access to a wide range of carriers. This means we can shop around and compare policies from multiple insurers to find the best coverage for you at the most competitive rates. This saves you time and effort of obtaining quotes from various insurers and provides you with more options to choose from.

Customized Coverage Image

Customized Coverage

Insurance needs vary from person to person, and a one-size-fits-all approach may not always be suitable. As an independent insurance agent, we have the flexibility to customize coverage based on your specific needs and requirements. This ensures that your insurance policies are tailored to your unique risks, providing you with adequate protection and peace of mind.

Claims Assistance Image

Claims Assistance

In the unfortunate event of a claim, having an experienced insurance agent by your side can be invaluable. We can provide guidance and support throughout the claims process, helping you navigate the paperwork, understand the coverage, and advocate on your behalf with the insurance company. This can help streamline the claims process and ensure that you receive the compensation you are entitled to.

Long-Term Relationship Image

Long-Term Relationship

By working with an independent insurance agent, together we can establish a long-term relationship based on trust and familiarity. As your insurance needs change over time, we can proactively review and update your policies to ensure that you continue to have adequate coverage. This ongoing relationship allows us to provide you personalized service, answer your questions, and be your trusted advisor for all their insurance needs.

Insurance for Life’s Uncertainties

We offer a wide range of insurance products to protect you against various risks, including:

Home & Property Insurance

Our home insurance policies are designed to safeguard your property, belongings, and personal liability. We offer coverage for homeowners, renters, and landlords, with options for dwelling coverage, personal property coverage, liability coverage, and more.

  • Home & Property
  • Homeowner’s Insurance
  • Umbrella
  • Condominium
  • Rental Property
  • Renter’s Insurance
  • Flood Insurance
  • K9
  • Liability

Auto & Recreational Vehicle Insurance

Whether you need coverage for your personal vehicle or a commercial fleet, our auto insurance policies can provide liability, collision, comprehensive, and other coverage options to keep you protected on the road.

  • Auto
  • Motorcycle
  • Watercraft
  • ATV & Off-Road
  • RV & Mobile Home
  • Classic Auto Boat
  • Sr-22

Umbrella Insurance

For added liability protection beyond the limits of your primary policies, our umbrella insurance provides an extra layer of coverage to safeguard your assets and financial well-being.

Business Insurance

As a business owner in Northeast Ohio, protecting your assets and operations is crucial. Our business insurance solutions can cover your property, liability, workers’ compensation, commercial auto, and other business-related risks.

  • Business Insurance
  • General Liability
  • Commercial Property
  • Commercial Auto
  • Excess Liability
  • Rental Property
  • Surety Bonds
  • More

Health Insurance

We also offer health insurance coverage to help individuals and families secure access to quality healthcare services, including medical, dental, vision, and prescription drug coverage.

  • Employee Benefits
  • Group Insurance
  • Medicare
  • Supplements
  • Medicare Advantage
  • Plans Healthcare
  • Exchange Disability
  • Insurance
  • Retirement Plans

Life Insurance

Planning for the future is important, and our life insurance policies can provide financial protection to your loved ones in the event of your passing. We offer term life, whole life, and universal life insurance options to fit your needs and budget.

Professional Liability Insurance

also known as professional indemnity or errors and omissions insurance, protects professionals from financial loss due to alleged negligence or mistakes in their professional services. It covers costs such as legal defense fees, settlements, and damages. It is important for professionals to have this insurance to safeguard their assets and focus on their work.

Home & Property  Insurance Image
Auto & Recreational Vehicle Insurance Image
Umbrella Insurance Image
Business Insurance Image
Health Insurance Image
Life Insurance Image
Professional Liability Insurance Image

Customer Testimonials That Warm Our Souls!

“Hands down the best customer service you will ever experience when it comes to insurance. I have been with this company since the day they opened and they will forever have my loyalty! You will not regret working with Denise!”

Sarah Poling

I have been with Eveningstar Insurance for over 10 yrs and have been a very happy customer. Denise treats you like you are a part of her family. I always recommend family, friends and customers every chance I get.

Kimberly Cheney Devlin

I shopped around for a good quote on insurance for my business and auto and Denise went out of her way to search out the best rates for me. She was on top of things and in no time I was paying less and getting more for my money. The people at Evening Star are great to work with and very friendly. Very Impressed!

Alarm1 Security and Video

This place is wonderful!!! The most kind, caring and understanding people! I had the pleasure of working with them and highly recommend them!

Roxanne Might

Most affordable insurance I’ve ever had. These guys are the best! They’ll shop around and find the right price for any of your insurance needs.

Rick Bullinger

Request a quote Take a Step Towards Peace of Mind

We understand that not all insurance policies are created equal. By filling out and submitting the form below, you’ll be taking a proactive step towards receiving a customized insurance solution that fits your unique needs. We’ll be in touch shortly.

What would you like a quote for?

(Check all that apply.)